Wrongful Death vs Survival Action Claims_ What’s the Difference_ Image

If your family member or loved one has died in an accident due to another’s negligence or wrongdoing, there are two potential legal paths to receiving financial compensation: a wrongful death claim or a survival action claim. Although similar, these two types of claims have different focuses and meet different ends. This article will cover the main things you need to know about a wrongful death vs. survival action claim and the differences between the two.

What Is a Wrongful Death?

A wrongful death is a death that was caused by the wrongful neglect, default, or act of another. A wrongful death claim can be brought by the personal representative of the deceased’s estate for the benefit of the surviving family members. Wrongful death claims serve to recover losses the deceased’s relatives and dependents suffered because of the death, such as loss of financial support.

For example, say the sole income earner of a home died in an accident. The deceased’s personal representative can bring a wrongful death action for the surviving spouse and children to secure compensation for losses they suffered.

Wrongful death claims can encompass a wide range of circumstances, including:

  • Car accidents
  • Work accidents
  • Slip-and-fall accidents
  • Malpractice
  • Defective products
  • Violent crimes

Note that South Dakota law explicitly defines the loss of an unborn child as grounds for initiating a wrongful death claim.

What Is Survival Action?

A survival action is a claim the deceased’s legal representatives bring to recover losses the deceased’s estate suffered because of their injuries.

For example, imagine someone sustained substantial injuries in a car accident due to another driver’s negligence. After six months of medical care, they pass away from their injuries. The deceased’s estate could file a survival action lawsuit against any responsible parties to cover any losses the deceased sustained during those six months. One way to think of a survival action claim is a personal injury claim that the deceased would have brought if they survived their injuries.

What’s the Main Difference Between a Wrongful Death Case and a Survival Action?

The core differences between wrongful death and survival action claims are when the losses were incurred and who benefits from the award. In both cases, the personal representative of the deceased’s estate files the lawsuit.

In a survival action claim, the plaintiff seeks compensation for the losses incurred by the deceased prior to their death. This can include medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering. Any compensation is paid to the deceased’s estate, which distributes it according to their will.

In a wrongful death claim, the plaintiff seeks compensation for the losses suffered by the family because of the death of their loved one. Any compensation goes directly to the deceased’s spouse or children. If no spouse or children exist, then the parents and next of kin of the deceased will get the money.

Compensation for Wrongful Death and Survival Action

Survival action claims compensate the deceased’s estate for any losses the deceased suffered as a direct result of their accident, such as:

  • Lost earnings
  • Medical bills
  • Pain and suffering

In contrast, compensation in wrongful death claims redress the losses of surviving family members. These losses can include:

  • Loss of financial support
  • Funeral expenses
  • Emotional pain
  • Loss of consortium
  • Loss of support and guidance

Factors that can affect the compensation in a wrongful death claim include the deceased’s age, occupation, and potential for career advancement. A Watertown wrongful death attorney can calculate the losses of both the surviving family members and the deceased’s estate and fight for the maximum compensation in either case.

Who Can Make a Wrongful Death Claim and Survival Action Claim?

South Dakota Law states that only the personal representative of the deceased’s estate can make a wrongful death claim. The same is true for a survival action. In either case, if the deceased named an executor in their will, that person can initiate the claims. If there was no will or if the deceased did not name an executor, the state can appoint a representative for the estate.

In some cases, eligibility for the two types of claims can overlap. If so, it is possible to simultaneously make a wrongful death claim and survival action claim and receive compensation for both.

It can often be beneficial to bring both types of claims. Specifically, a survival action claim can fill gaps in financial compensation from a wrongful death claim. For instance, the proceeds from a wrongful death claim may not cover outstanding medical bills the deceased’s estate still owes. In that case, a survival action claim can fill any gaps in compensation.

The legal processes for the two claims are different, so you’ll need to work with a personal injury attorney who can handle both claims for you.

What Is the Statute of Limitations for Wrongful Death and Survival Action Claims?

Wrongful Death vs Survival Action Claims_ What’s the Difference_ Image 2

The statute of limitations for both wrongful death claims and survival action claims in South Dakota is three years from the death of the individual (SDCL 23-5-3).

Note that in South Dakota, the statute of limitations for suing the state is only one year from the date of the death (SDCL 21-32-2). Additionally, you must provide the state with notice of your intent to sue within 180 days of the injury (SDCL 3-21-2).

Get Qualified Legal Help Today

Regardless of the circumstances of your case, the sooner you take action, the better. Getting started on your claim early gives your Watertown wrongful death attorney enough time to build a strong case and maximize your chances of receiving financial compensation.

Don’t worry if you think you can’t afford a lawyer. Turbak Law Office, P.C. works on a contingency fee basis. That means you pay nothing upfront, and you don’t pay us until we secure compensation for you. Our fees will be an agreed-upon percentage of your compensation.

Send Turbak Law Office, P.C. a message today or call 605-886-8361 to discuss your wrongful death or survival action claims. We will treat you with compassion and provide the support you need at this difficult time.

Results
$11,000,000 Settlement Car Accident
$4,007,015.24 Settlement Semi Truck Collisions
$3,450,000 Settlement Motorcycle Accidents
$2,500,000 Settlement Wrongful Death
$2,500,000 Settlement Wrongful Death
Client Testimonials
a beacon of excellence in the legal field

3 years ago I found myself in the unfortunate position of being involved in a car accident. Amidst the chaos and stress, Turbak Law Office became my guiding light, and I am beyond grateful for their exceptional support and dedication throughout the entire process.

From the moment I reached out to Turbak Law Office, their team displayed a level of professionalism and empathy that immediately put me at ease. They listened attentively to my concerns, thoroughly explained the legal proceedings, and outlined a strategy that gave me confidence in the path forward.

What truly sets Turbak Law Office apart is their unwavering commitment to their clients. Throughout the entire duration of my case, they were proactive in keeping me informed, consistently updating me on any developments, and promptly addressing any questions or concerns I had along the way. Their communication was clear, concise, and always delivered with a genuine concern for my well-being.

I cannot recommend Turbak Law Office highly enough. Their dedication, professionalism, and genuine care for their clients make them stand out as a beacon of excellence in the legal field. If you find yourself in need of legal representation, look no further than Turbak Law Office – they are truly the best in the business. Thank you, Dillon Martinez, Seamus Turbak, and the entire Turbak team, for all that you have done for me and my family.

Carlito E.
You guys are amazing!

There determination and hardwork helped us settle a claim that I thought was going to be impossible. I was told that Turbak is the best and everyone is right! So thankful for their expertise! You guys are amazing!

Jessie B.
Great people, great service!!

Great people, great service!! Always answered any questions right away! Dillon was also an amazing, helpful, kind person. He always had a smile on his face and took a lot of stress off my shoulders. Not once did I leave there feeling unsatisfied! 10/10 🙂

Quinn L.
exceedingly efficient and effective

I cannot thank Turbak Law enough for the time and effort they put in to bring closure to one of the most difficult times I have ever had to deal with. They were exceedingly efficient and effective in bringing a positive result and were able and willing to work around my schedule. Thank you to Seamus and Erika for all the work and support through all.

Tanya H.