In a car accident claim, you may face challenges in pursuing compensation for your injuries and losses because another driver or party involved in the case has given false information or testimony to the police, insurance company, or the court. When you have an insurance claim denied or face losing a car accident lawsuit because the other party lied about the crash, what options do you have to protect your rights and interests? For example, can you sue someone for lying about a car accident and now deny liability for causing the accident?

Potential Claims Against Someone for Making False Statements About a Car Accident

When another party involved in your car accident claim knowingly gives false statements about the crash to the police or insurance company, adversely affecting your legal rights and interests, you may have legal claims to hold that party accountable for their conduct. For example, can you sue someone for lying about a car accident? You may have a fraud claim against a party who knowingly makes a false statement that you rely upon to your detriment, such as including that statement in an insurance claim, which results in the insurance company denying the claim. You might also have a defamation claim when a party knowingly makes a false statement that harms your reputation, such as accusing you of reckless driving and triggering a criminal prosecution.

Consequences of Making a False Car Accident Report to the Police

Under South Dakota law, a person who provides false information to law enforcement about a car accident or files a crash report containing false information may face prosecution for false reporting to authorities, a Class 1 misdemeanor. A conviction for false reporting to authorities may result in a penalty that includes up to one year of incarceration in a county jail, a fine of up to $2,000, or both incarceration and fines.

A person who provides false information or testimony in a car accident case, such as in a deposition or trial testimony given under oath or affirmation, may also face prosecution on perjury charges. South Dakota law defines perjury as occurring when a person, after taking an oath to testify or certify as accurate before a tribunal, officer, or person in any state or federal action or proceeding in which a party may administer oaths, intentionally states material information they know to be false. Perjury constitutes a felony offense, with the grading of the felony dependent on whether the perjury occurs in a felony trial (Class 3 felony), in any other trial, court proceeding, deposition, or administrative proceeding conducted under oath (Class 5 felony), or any other matter proscribed by law (Class 6 felony). Penalties for a perjury conviction can include:

  • Class 3 felony: Up to 15 years in prison and a potential fine of up to $30,000
  • Class 5 felony: Up to five years in prison and a potential fine of up to $10,000
  • Class 6 felony: Up to two years in prison and a potential fine of up to $4,000

The Implications of a Car Accident Witness Lying to the Insurance Company

A driver or witness who provides materially false information in a car accident insurance claim may cause various adverse consequences for accident victims and face penalties for their behavior. Unfortunately, when a person provides false information in a car accident claim, the insurance company may rely on that information to wrongly deny a driver’s or passenger’s injury or property damage claim. If you ask yourself, can you sue someone for lying about a car accident, the answer can depend on the circumstances. A person who knowingly lies to an insurance company may face the consequences if the insurer discovers the lie; the insurer may report the person to law enforcement for potential prosecution for insurance fraud, especially if the person’s lies allowed them to secure insurance benefits or compensation.

However, an insurance company that relies on false information to deny a car accident claim may open themselves to a bad faith claim filed by a claimant. When an insurance company uses information knowing that the person who provided that information lied, or an insurer knowingly disregards facts that would cause a reasonable party to dispute the veracity of the person’s information or statement, they may become liable to a claimant whose car accident claim they deny in a bad faith claim.

Steps to Take After Getting Wrongly Accused of a Car Accident

When the other party in your car accident case has falsely blamed you for causing the crash, you can take steps to protect your rights and interests by:

  • Request copies of the police accident report.
  • Speak to eyewitnesses to the crash to obtain statements about what they saw.
  • Recover copies of dashcam footage from vehicles involved in or near the crash and copies of traffic/surveillance camera footage.
  • Gather evidence you obtained after the accident, such as photos/videos of the accident scene.

Finally, contact a car accident attorney who can help you build a compelling case to prove the falsity of the other party’s testimony, including by obtaining accident reconstruction expert reports and testimony that persuasively explain how the other party’s account could not have happened.

Challenging in Proving the Other Party Lied About the Crash

You may face various challenges to obtain relief from a party who intentionally makes a false statement in your car accident claim. First, you must prove the falsity of the other party’s statements, which may require you to gather substantial or compelling evidence to eliminate any doubt about the falsity of the other person’s statements. Second, you must prove that the other party knew they provided false information, which may prove challenging as parties rarely obtain direct evidence of a person’s culpability in providing false information.

Contact a Car Accident Attorney Today

When another party involved in your car accident case has knowingly provided false information, testimony, or evidence, get the legal help you need to protect your rights and interests. Contact Watertown car accident lawyer at Turbak Law Office, P.C. today or call 605-886-8361 for a free, no-obligation consultation to discuss your options when someone lies and adversely affects your car accident claim.

Related Posts:

Why Do Insurance Companies Deny Claims?

What Is the Discovery Process in a Lawsuit?

Compensatory vs. Punitive Damages: What’s the Difference?

Why You Need a Car Accident Attorney Even for the Smallest Collisions

Your Vehicle Was Wrecked, and It Wasn’t Your Fault! Now What?

Results
$11,000,000 Settlement Car Accident
$4,007,015.24 Settlement Semi Truck Collisions
$3,450,000 Settlement Motorcycle Accidents
$2,500,000 Settlement Wrongful Death
$2,500,000 Settlement Wrongful Death
Client Testimonials
a beacon of excellence in the legal field

3 years ago I found myself in the unfortunate position of being involved in a car accident. Amidst the chaos and stress, Turbak Law Office became my guiding light, and I am beyond grateful for their exceptional support and dedication throughout the entire process.

From the moment I reached out to Turbak Law Office, their team displayed a level of professionalism and empathy that immediately put me at ease. They listened attentively to my concerns, thoroughly explained the legal proceedings, and outlined a strategy that gave me confidence in the path forward.

What truly sets Turbak Law Office apart is their unwavering commitment to their clients. Throughout the entire duration of my case, they were proactive in keeping me informed, consistently updating me on any developments, and promptly addressing any questions or concerns I had along the way. Their communication was clear, concise, and always delivered with a genuine concern for my well-being.

I cannot recommend Turbak Law Office highly enough. Their dedication, professionalism, and genuine care for their clients make them stand out as a beacon of excellence in the legal field. If you find yourself in need of legal representation, look no further than Turbak Law Office – they are truly the best in the business. Thank you, Dillon Martinez, Seamus Turbak, and the entire Turbak team, for all that you have done for me and my family.

Carlito E.
You guys are amazing!

There determination and hardwork helped us settle a claim that I thought was going to be impossible. I was told that Turbak is the best and everyone is right! So thankful for their expertise! You guys are amazing!

Jessie B.
Great people, great service!!

Great people, great service!! Always answered any questions right away! Dillon was also an amazing, helpful, kind person. He always had a smile on his face and took a lot of stress off my shoulders. Not once did I leave there feeling unsatisfied! 10/10 🙂

Quinn L.
exceedingly efficient and effective

I cannot thank Turbak Law enough for the time and effort they put in to bring closure to one of the most difficult times I have ever had to deal with. They were exceedingly efficient and effective in bringing a positive result and were able and willing to work around my schedule. Thank you to Seamus and Erika for all the work and support through all.

Tanya H.